Blog Archives

WEXIT: Assessing the Costs

Posted on by 0 comment

For the record, I don’t want Alberta or Saskatchewan to separate from the rest of Canada. There has to be a better solution to making Confederation work.

Unfortunately, Andrew Scheer, Jason Kenney, Scott Moe (Canada’s Three Wexiteers) and many others like to talk about the benefits of ‘WEXIT’, or Western-Exit. Like I didn’t hear enough of that garbage with Britain.

Now immature and assinine ‘separatists’ want to leave Canada so that they can get their pipelines built for shitumen.

Like this one.

Because who doesn’t want a multi-billion dollar bilge pump in their own backyard? Why would Ontario and Quebec want to invest in green energy and the future when they could be steamrolled by dirty oil?

FFS, I mean even SAUDI ARABIA is getting out of the oil business and is moving to sell it’s state-owned oil company, ARAMCO.

(I’m sure the Wexiteers will find a way to blame Trudeau for that mess, too).

Assessing the Costs and Not Just the Benefits …

For starters, there’s the massive subsidies that Canada pumps into the West in the form of direct and indirect subsidies.

To the tune of $1,650 for every single citizen of this country.

$60 billion is the estimate from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) for 2015 ALONE.

Canada continues to subsidize the fossil fuel industry in myriad ways. First, it provides tax breaks under the federal Income Tax Act. For example, in 2015 the federal government introduced a new accelerated depreciation rate for equipment used in LNG facilities, which was a change proposed by the Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers.

Second, government provides funding to the fossil fuel industry at favourable rates through direct financing and loan guarantees. A recent example is Export Development Canada’s administration of a nearly $5 billion loan to support the government’s controversial purchase and operation of the Trans Mountain pipeline.

Ottawa has no plan to recoup that principal cost from industry — and is also subsidizing half the interest expense with taxpayer dollars.

Third, Canada provides direct funding to the fossil fuel industry through research, development and other services provided by federal agencies.

For example, the federal government is paying $1.5 billion for the Oceans Protection Plan, an initiative to safeguard bitumen transport through the Port of Vancouver. This plan was necessitated by new oil tanker traffic — and should be paid for by oil shippers.

Finally, there is the $60 billion subsidy that the IMF focused on — the “social costs” of carbon that governments pay, instead of fuel producers.

Lacking adequate carbon taxes, governments continue to pick up the tab for the impacts of climate change — for example, repairing damage from extreme weather events, building new levees, sea walls and storm sewers and paying for wildfire control and increased health costs.

Here are some other potential costs to the west if they were to seriously consider / implement separation:

  • Treaty agreements would be reopened and, as the saying goes, Westerners won’t have anything but the dirt under their fingernails once Canada’s First Nations people are finished with them (with Canada’s support, of course).
  • Open-ended natural gas lines to eastern consumers would vaporize. That recurring cash flow you get from the rest of Canada? It’ll dry up sooner than you think. Canadians would quickly adjust their building code and find ways to replace gas heaters.
  • Reclamations costs to bring what they had back to what it was. The cost of repairing and replacing massive leaching ponds and waste disposal. The incalculable damage that’s been done to line the pockets of Albertans
  • Loss of their portion of the CPP and other pension funds. Let’s see if Canada wants to give it back to the west.
  • Complete loss of leverage for building additional pipelines in the future without over-the-top penalties or royalties for the east as part of the plan.

A Reminder …

Under a decade of Stephen Harper, Ontario and Quebec suffered.

I won’t let anyone in the west forget that.

We sacrificed millions of good, reliable, full-time jobs for the benefit of western oil producers (a high dollar meant our manufacturing exports were uncompetitive, but oil exports were incredibly profitable). Stephen Harper did little to stem the tide and we don’t want those kind of Conservatives back at the table again. Ever.

And it was Stephen Harper who was whispering in the ears of people like Donald Trump during NAFTA renogtiations

As people’s lives were thrown into complete disarray en masse, did the east talk about separation? Well, Quebec always does, but I don’t know what to say about that. Ontario has held strong despite the losses.

As I said, it would be a tragedy to treat these children like adults and give them the opportunity to separate from Canada without a good discourse about the VERY REAL COST of separation.

Category: Uncategorized

Wexit, Canada, Norway and $1.3 Trillion

Posted on by 0 comment

I snapped this quote the other day and wanted to share it:

I’m putting this here for a LOT of reasons. $1.3 trillion reasons.

That’s right: the Government Pension Fund of Norway is worth $1.3 trillion and is moving on from oil-based investments.

1.3 trillion reasons why anti-Canadians like Jason Kenney, Scott Moe, Andrew Scheer and other Conservatives are content to stick their heads in the sand and ignore global issues associated with dirty oil.

1.3 trillion reasons why no one wants your dirty shitumen.  (Get it? Shitty bitumen? I mean, if you can do it with western exit, I can do it with something that’s a more realistic reflection of reality.)

1.3 trillion reasons why oil prices, especially those concerning shitumen, are plummeting.

1.3 trillion reasons why blaming Ontario and Quebec for your lack of diversification and lack is not a good idea and why people in the east of Canada don’t think dumping hard-earned tax dollars into pipelines is a good idea.

1.3 trillion reasons why 40 years of Conservatives is destroying your province, dig by dig doesn’t justify blaming the ‘blip-in-time’ NDP government, Trudeau or anyone other than yourselves.

1.3 trillion reasons why the future is not based on carbon production.

1.3 trillion reasons why we ALL need to look beyond OUR shitumen resource base and start some serious planning for Canada’s future.


C’mon Cons: even zeros like you should be able to recognize something on the positive side of ledger.

PS be careful what you wish for with exit from Canada threats. 100% of lands in Manitoba, Alberta, Saskatchewan and even BC are based FIRST on treaty agreements with Canada’s First Nations people that were signed BEFORE these provinces joined Confederation. Separation would legally nullify your existence as provinces and put 100% of the power into the hands of the people that should have it: Canada’s First Nations people.

Category: Uncategorized

Will This Story Be Big Enough By Monday Morning?

Posted on by 0 comment

The heads of Canadian political geeks are exploding right now.

The news about political consultant Warren Kinsella being hired by the Conservative Party of Canada to discredit the People’s Party of Canada is quite unsettling.

Details here.

SOOOOO many questions I don’t know where to begin.

We’re at the 11th hour. For some reason, the Andrew Scheer Conservatives might still win 100+ seats, but as we’ve witnessed over the last few days, they’ll resort to anything to win.

Is that the government we want for Canada?

Category: Uncategorized

Why Minority Governments Are Representative of Democracy In Action

Posted on by 0 comment

Minority governments should be the way to go.

Of course, there are some folks out there who live in a little bubble of ‘my way or the highway’ and who refuse to accept that they are being hired by us to negotiate what’s best for all of us.

That’s the thing: ALL of us have to negotiate something at any given moment during the hours and days of our lives. Choices have to be made, but more importantly, some of those choices are the result of discussions, negotiations and practical conclusions reached by cooperating with others.

It’s life.

Our democratic institutions should do a better job of reflecting this.

However, Andrew Scheer, not knowing how Parliament works (ie. you have to actually organize a majority of seats in order to guide the direction of the House of Commons) has proposed that a minority government would be the worst kind of suffering that Canadians would have to endure.

No, quite the contrary Andrew. I think Justin, Jagmeet, Elizabeth and maybe even a few of your henchmen would be able to survive congenial discussions about how to run our country.

And the jaws of Hell won’t open up and consume us for a thousand years.

In fact, I propose that as part of electoral reform, representatives would NOT be able to keep shutting down government in a hissy fit of tantrums every time they disagree with each other.

Chrystia Freeland didn’t get to walk away from Trump. She had to negotiate, along with a team of professionals, to ensure that we got the best deal possible under dire circumstances. And Stephen Harper actively trying to sabotage the deal.

There you have it: when we elect governments, they can’t request an election until 4 years out. If nothing gets done, hire an arbitrator. If they still can’t do anything, so be it.

I’d sooner have a constipated government than Conservatives running loose with every piece of legislation designed to protect our human rights, economy and dignity.

Category: Uncategorized

A Scheer Abundance of Lies

Posted on by 0 comment

Andrew Scheer opens his mouth. He lies.

Here’s a recap of some of his most recent lies and those spread by the Conservative Party of Canada:


Add the biggest whopper of late, which is the increase in GST that the Liberals and NDP would bring in if elected.

(For the record, I would support a huge increase in consumption taxes in favour of a sweeping overhaul of our tax system, but that’s a whole other discussion).

When someone is so chronic with the lies they spread, why do they still have supporters?

I don’t understand.

Category: Uncategorized